Tragic Drowning During Baptism: Pastor Charged with Manslaughter

A baptism streamed to a small online congregation has ended in tragedy, marking the beginning of a criminal case. A 61-year-old man drowned during the ceremony in Birmingham, leading to serious legal consequences for the pastor involved.

Incident Overview

On October 8, 2023, Robert Smith, a grandfather of seven from Brixton, south London, tragically lost his life while participating in a baptism conducted by 48-year-old Pastor Cheryl Bartley. The incident occurred at a residential property on Slade Road in Erdington, prompting immediate emergency response efforts.

Charges Against Pastor Cheryl Bartley

Pastor Bartley has been charged with one count of gross negligence manslaughter and is slated to appear at Birmingham Magistrates’ Court on May 14. The ceremony took place in a small paddling pool set up in the garden, which was livestreamed on Facebook by Life Changing Ministries, the church Bartley is associated with. The livestream was abruptly cut off during the incident and later removed.

Background of the Victim

Robert Smith had been living with Parkinson’s disease and was known as a long-standing member of the congregation. According to a Facebook post from the church, Smith had been part of the community for four years, returning for a baptism after having previously been baptized as a teenager. He sought this second ceremony as a "born again believer."

Emergency Response

Despite emergency services administering advanced life support at the scene, Smith could not be revived and was pronounced dead before he reached the hospital. Originally from Jamaica, Smith had lived in the UK for over 25 years and was preparing to welcome his eighth grandchild.

Legal Proceedings

The Crown Prosecution Service confirmed the charges against Pastor Bartley following an investigation by the West Midlands Police. Malcolm McHaffie, head of the CPS Special Crime Division, stated, “We have decided to prosecute Cheryl Bartley with one count of gross negligence manslaughter in relation to her role as a pastor during a baptism.” He emphasized that sufficient evidence had been gathered to proceed with legal action.

Court Proceedings and Sensitivities

As the case approaches court, McHaffie reminded the public of the legal sensitivities involved, asserting that it is essential to avoid any reporting or commentary that could potentially prejudice the case. The exact circumstances surrounding Smith’s drowning during the baptism remain unclear, and further details will be revealed as judicial proceedings unfold.

This tragic event underlines the importance of safety during religious ceremonies and the potential legal ramifications when something goes awry. As this case continues to develop, it highlights the complexities involved in balancing personal faith with public responsibility.